Ratings Guidelines :

1 star - poor - low quality idea and/or execution. A poor entry.
2 stars - the idea is unoriginal and/or execution is below average in quality. A below average entry.
3 stars - interesting idea / concept with fair to good execution. A good entry
4 stars - interesting idea / concept with strong execution. A strong entry.
5 stars - exceptional idea and execution. A standout entry.

Giving a 1 star rating is really disrespectful. We, designers, working without guarantee to be paid for you and your business.

does he give you 1 star Raoul?